New Providence Cemetery

New Providence was one of the first churches in North America to have an adjacent cemetery. Many of the oldest gravestones are unreadable or have fallen over time. We welcome visitors to come and research their ancestry in our cemetery. We hold additional records in our History Room.

Click for Cemetery Map

Cemetery directory

now online!

Exciting news! The New Providence Cemetery Directory is now available online. We owe a huge debt of gratitude to Rachel Koeniger who has spent years compiling this information, proofreading, filling in missing data, proofreading, formatting, proofreading, reformatting, proofreading and making every effort to ensure accuracy! This version is current as of December 31, 2025. Thank you, Rachel for your labor of love!

Cemetery Directory